• Bleach: The Thousand-Year Blood War - Part 3: The Conflict is expected to arrive in 2024. Until then, check out the latest news from the Bleach Anime Section: HERE! ~ The BA staff.

Burn the Witch 1 "Witches Blow A New Pipe": Spoilers and Discussions

How do you rate Burn the Witch chapter 1 and why?

  • 3 - Good

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 2 - Passable

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 1 - Not good

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    16
  • Poll closed .

NeoPlatonist

Life is a song cue . . .
Joined
May 12, 2013
Messages
902
Reaction score
1,296
Points
4,041
On a more serious note, given that Kubo originally only drew this for his family and friends and as a favor to the WSJ Editor in Chief for WSJ's 50th anniversary, I think this series is the best understood as a cute, fun, short experience, the celebration of Kubo's artwork.
Thanks for this reminder - I was aware of these details a couple years ago, but had completely forgotten them in the current context. To be fair, as something originally drawn for family and friends, this would be in a different category. :eagerness

Regarding Sullivan's prettiness - I recall that Wandenreicher Hubert was also similarly drawn. Here's a comparison of the two:
vTQTf8q.png
 
Last edited:
Joined
Jun 2, 2013
Messages
8,852
Reaction score
2,060
Points
7,541
Beautiful lashes on both Hubert and Sullivan, NeoPlatonist! :XD

I am more confident now that Tite Kubo's Burn the Witch could be successful enough so that there is demand for more. If so, I think it is possible that we will get another set of four issues in another limited series eventually, giving Tite Kubo as much time as he needs to complete it without harming his health.

That would certainly be interesting. Many mangaka who achieved success with a super-long series are reluctant to return to the weekly magazine. However, I would welcome it if Kubo was willing to do something like a designated run of 10 to 15 chapter mini-series every year or so, be it in WSJ or any other Shueisha magazine/platform. WSJ is willing to wait for Togashi to return from his hiatuses, so maybe it wouldn't have been a bad idea to allow established authors to return with mini-series every now and again.
 

Deathking

Carpe Diem
Joined
Mar 24, 2013
Messages
518
Reaction score
173
Points
76
I would be interested in a monthly Kubo manga of 25 pages per chapter so he does not over exert himself. Monthly chapters are usually less stressful than weekly chapters.
 
Joined
Jun 12, 2015
Messages
105
Reaction score
32
Points
1
I found this chapter to be surprisingly enjoyable, and I actually prefer it to the one-shot. I like the characterization we got for Ninny and Noel, and all the world building thrown in. Also, from the animated panels from the anime trailer, this whole thing is gonna look SWEET in color. I do like how cute Osushi (Ousushi?) is, and the fact that they downplayed Balgo. I think he works better as a minor char, and definitely prefer him to the one shot.

The negative
I gotta say I'm a bit disappointed with the character designs. Qquntnire looks like Candace, Bruno looks like Bazz B, dude from Accounting looks like Kisuke, then we got Rukia/Uryuu in the Sabers, and Yhwach (!!!) in the Gallows. Smh. I thought Kubo copying his faces in the TYBW arc was bad, but this is kind of a bit... blatant. I'm sure he's doing it for his fans but eh. Also, as some people have pointed out, Sullivan's name scheme with the SS was a bit... problematic. And I could have done without Ninny's actual panty shot. Also what was the throw-away line about social justice I wonder? I'm assuming that was a mistranslation? (Although that does seem like it will be an important theme later on with Balgo's execution). Anyway.

The positive
I gotta say that I've always been reluctant about Burn the Witch being set in Bleach universe. Mainly, it's the relationship between Hollows and Dragons that irked me, since I had formerly assumed that Hollows were a widespread phenomena in the world of the living. (They still are, just not in London, I guess). This chapter has assuaged some of my fears, however, since it seems that Reverse London is a direct overlay of physical (Front) London. That's kind of cool, tbh, and I loved the little details such as "Reverse BBC," the conversion between front world and reverse world currency, and "Dragon Insurance," XD. Also, I loved the introduction of a magic system with spells. Reverse London seems to be fairly small, "geographically" speaking, since Balgo is the first Dragonclad who has appeared in 96 years. Either that or Wing Bind is WAY more effective at management than the East Branch Soul Society, which I guess is also a possibility, heh.

Questions I have:
1. I wonder how the Sacreds (Liturgy) and Anthems (Incantations) divisions differ from each other? Also, when Ninny used the tape barrier, I wonder if that's something the "magic circle" division specializes in ("containment barriers"), or if magic circles are something else (like one of the other users mentioned).

2. What if the witches and wizards in reverse London are... Quincy? (Or descendants of them). They seem to be resistant to "dragontoxins", meaning they have some sort of natural anti-bodies to dragons. They could also be a form of Fullbringer, I suppose, but given what we know about Fullbringers from the Light Novel, that seems less likely, although the way Kubo describes dragontoxins seems similar to how he described Fullbringers' relation to Hollows. Quincies were also prevalent in Europe during Yhwach's campaign from a thousand years ago, and England isn't too far from Germany. Not to mention, the wands seem to be more similar to Spirit Weapons than anything else we've seen, and wizards and witches do seem to be alive (vs. undead or spirits themselves like the Shinigami) so that would make sense. Anyway, that's just a loose headcanon I have for now.

I wish I had read the one shot before this chapter, since I forgot the specifics of dark dragons, wands, etc. Looking forward to how Kubo develops the Dragonclad stuff later on, plus the shady stuff that seems to be going on in the Top of Horns.

Overall, 4/5 for this chapter. Seems a bit crammed with exposition, but for me that was a good thing.
 
Joined
Jun 2, 2013
Messages
8,852
Reaction score
2,060
Points
7,541
I gotta say I'm a bit disappointed with the character designs. Qquntnire looks like Candace, Bruno looks like Bazz B, dude from Accounting looks like Kisuke, then we got Rukia/Uryuu in the Sabers, and Yhwach (!!!) in the Gallows.

While I agree that Wolfgang (the leader of Gallows) looks like a mix between Bach, Robert and Yamamoto, I see no resemblence between Cquntnire and Candace whatsoever. Bruno looks like a hotheaded type of character, so it's normal that people were reminded of Bazz-B, Renji. In my opinion, he looks rather original. Harry (Billionaires) reminds me far more of Gojo from Jujutsu Kaisen than Urahara.

And I could have done without Ninny's actual panty shot.

I've read the chapter again and couldn't find any panel that qualifies as a panty shot. Besides, she's wearing shorts as a part of the uniform, not a skirt. Before she goes to Reverse London, she is in a skirt, but when she jumps down, it's covering her thighs.
 
Top